Due to the previous “Rating characters” thread being inconsistent as a result of there being a lack of rules on said thread, me and the other staff members have decided to set up a new thread with a set of ground rules to make it more organised.
Please put the name of the character you’re asking to be rated even if you believe that said character is well known
Please include reasons for your rating. Said reasons don’t have to be particularly detailed (even writing a single sentence will do).
Please DO NOT leave reviews on characters you don’t know little/anything about (i.e. saying “I don’t know who this character is, sorry” before posting an image of another character), as this is unfair to whoever was the last person to comment on the thread, since they don’t end up receiving a review for their character.
Even if you dislike the character you’re reviewing, please try and be respectful in your review. Insulting reviews or troll reviews (e.g. 0/10 Luke Skywalker is a crap character who should not exist) are NOT acceptable.
Please DO NOT submit OCs on this thread.
Please be respectful to other users on this thread.
Any comments which go against these rules will be deleted, and the users who made them will be issued with Warnings and Blocks if necessary.
If you have any questions any of the rules on here, please let me know on my message wall.
This simple game was somehow overcomplicated in the previous thread. SMH.
Anyways, 7/10. Only experience I had with it was playing PvZ a long time ago. But I don't really feel any emotional attachment to it. Though, I will say it has saved me from countless Game Overs. So I think it deserves some respect.
I consider Optimus Prime to be a strong example of virtuous and noble characters, for a sentient robot from outerspace that protects us humans, I greatly respect how they manage to make him so inspiring, I certainly hold him in such a regard, 9/10
@Dedede Just to point out, one of the rules of this thread is that you should try and not review characters you don't know much about, so in the future if you see a character that you don't know much about, don't bother reviewing them and simply wait until a character is posted that you do know about before posting a review of said character along with a image of the character you want to be rated. Just wanted to help you regarding this situation.
Big the cat 10 wrote: @Dedede Just to point out, one of the rules of this thread is that you should try and not review characters you don't know much about, so in the future if you see a character that you don't know much about, don't bother reviewing them and simply wait until a character is posted that you do know about before posting a review of said character along with a image of the character you want to be rated. Just wanted to help you regarding this situation.
@Migue Thank you for your recommendation, it has now been added to the rules of this thread.
@everyone Just to let guys know, stating the name of the character you intend to submit for review is now compulsory (even if you believe said character to be quite well known), so I’d really appreciate it if you all do this in the future.
Bernadetta is honestly among the Greatest things in Fire Emblem: Three Houses due to how Relatable her Problems Are and how Relatable her Personality is in General, I honestly enjoyed her Supports Especially with Felix and Sylvain due to how Hilarious and How Adorable they were as well along with her Supports with Dorothea and Ingrid.
She's also probably among the Most Useful and Probably Best UNits in Fire Emblem: Three Houses, When Playing the Golden Deer, She is Among the Members of my God Archer Squad Comprised of Ashe, Claude, Shamir, and Leonie with Bernie honestly being the Greatest Member due to the Amount of Criticals she gets even before she was Promoted.
All in all? A Solid 10/10, Easily The Best Units in the Game and the Most Relatable.
Brainiac while I don't ahve much experince with him rom Injustice just seems intimidating and creepy with his intellegence and obsession with his collection. Overall a really great villain. 9/10. Nagisa Shiota (Assassination Classroom)
Please put the name of the character you’re asking to be rated even if you believe that said character is well known
I just wanted to remind you all of the following thread rule, since not everyone has been following it in the last couple of days. If everyone here does not name the character they are submitting for review, their posts will be at risk of being removed.
We're edging a bit on the unsubstantiated reviews again. Anyway, 5/10 honestly for that Powerpuff Girl. I've seen her mentioned and saw the episode she appeared within the Reboot. Her personality is fine I guess, but I think I personally just dislike the character because of forced diversity and all. That didn't affect my thoughts here, I think the character is just kind of bland and isn't on screen enough to have good development.
ah roxas sorras nobody he is a interesting charecter to say the least he was the unlucky 13th member. he is best friends of my favorite charecter axel. roxas is kind a goofball and it seems impossable to like the kid for me 9/10
Raditz was a decent villain whose reveal of Goku’s alien origins definitely changed the Dragon Ball franchise forever and arguably made it more interesting. His techniques and overall strength were also pretty impressive. However, the fact he was the brother of the main protagonist and he was killed after only a few episodes hardly ever to be mentioned again really let’s down his character for me, and I feel like he could have become a potential ally of Goku’s in the future and a major part of the Z-Fighters like Vegeta and Piccolo.
Dan was a breath of fresh air from the "jerk loner" shonen protagonists of yesteryear. His honest mistakes made him incredibly believable, and I think he's a great character in general, both in the original and, somehow, in the new show. I give him a solid 9/10.
My entry is Chobin, from Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness. Unconventional, I know, but I want to see what those of you who played the game think of him.
death stroak is such a good anti hero. he fights on both ends. he is edgy plays by his own rules. fights smart and dirty. a way a villian SHOULD be. he has a cool look as well good voice actors in the adds i have seen he is one charecter that can send fear into almost everyone. 10/10 for me
Samus has an interesting and engaging backstory, fun games and is a pretty good character overall. I haven't played Metroid to death, but from what I have played, Samus came across as a well-written and badass heroine. 9/10
Assuming that this is MCU Doctor Strange? If so, easily 10/10 for me. Strange has a pretty neat background and I like that even after the events of his movie, he at least wasn't just handed the title and exact same respect of the Sorcerer Supreme. Dude was an egotistical bore and became a pretty badass wielder of Magic. I particularly like time abilities, so the Eye of Agamotto is just really neat to see in his original movie and Infinity War. Let's not forget it also spawned the infamous meme of, D O R M A M M U, I ' V E C O M E T O B A R G A I N !
Shadow's pretty edgy, he does have downsides. At least he has actual quality tho unlike a lot of edgy characters out there. SOnic Adventure 2 was gud and he's alright all around. Shadow The Hedgehog (The Game) was unforgivable imo tho. 6.5/10
Ah yes Bane one of Batman's most interesting villains, whilst I don't know much about the comic book incarnation of the character what always fascinated me was his portrayal in the Arkham Series not to mention the Dark Knight Movies. I also really like how he's not truly insane in fact he's nearly as smart as Batman is, for instance having 3 different PHD's and a photographic memory as well as figuring out Batman's identity (and then breaking the Bat). Not to mention his gloriously underused Mexican accent solid 9.5/10 in my books.
He's frickin' awesome. Honestly, he's hilarious. He's my second favorite mario character and he's always been cool. I like the fact that in gameplay they try to differ him from Mario and he's always been more fun to use imo. Also in smash he's fun to troll people with. 10/10
Link is like video games’ Goku in a lot of ways(Im kinda of DBZ tard). Link is heroic, badass, helpful, and a great hero. To be honest, I think he’s my 2nd favorite video games protagonist after Sonic. 9/10
all might seems like a good hero. all though he reminds me to much of superman. when ever i see a superman rip off. i get angery. allmight has way to cocky. high self esteam. and overall kind of a show off. 2/10
how dare you insult our lord and saviour All Might
Nick Fury? yeah he's cool well at least the MCU version of him is, he ain't taking any shit from anybody plus he's played by Sam Jackson that's always a plus 10/10
Darth Maul's pretty neat overall. Double bladed lightsaber, sith in training, and badass humanoid design qualify as being pretty good qualities. Even better with his Clone Wars adaptation where he took on Obi Wan for one last showdown, albeit brief, was pretty epic. 7.5/10
A lot of people hate him but Pokemon, especially the anime was a big thing in my childhood. While around Best Wishes I wasn't able to watch anymore as my fam no longer had cable, I woke up every Saturday Morning happily anticipating the new episodes of Pokemon Battle Dimensions all the way to Pokemon Black and White. In my late teens I bingewatched all of Pokemon X and Y all the way through all that is currently out of Sun & Moon Ultra Guardians with my little bro who's become a BIG fan of the series. And inbetween that I took the time to binge Indigo League through most of Orange Islands. Ash is someone I can look upon and always be fond about due to hwo much nostalgia I have for the anime and how it connects me with my younger brother still today. Hearing that he not only caught an Ultra Beast but also a Mythical Pokemon and eveolved both, and won the league just made me so happy I can't even put it into words. Ash EASILY gets a 10/10 from me.
On the topic of Pokemon... how would you guys rate one of my personal favorite Pokemon, and one of my most wanted newcomers for Smash Bros. Eevee?
I mean I guess his overall concept was cool and I do have to admit I love his fashion sense (plus his amazing quotes) but honestly being here has really made me develop a negative opinion of both Bill and Gravity Falls, which is a shame because I used to love the show and Bill as a character before everything became way too complex to keep track of not just in universe but also in terms of VS Debating. Still he's at least a solid 7/10 to me.
blazikin is a good pokemon. im the misty for fire pokemon...and yes i know its def gen idk i love any fire pokemon. but i like him because of his design his attacks and his name. and his first evalution torchic just plain adorable....so its a 10/10 for me
Luigi is incredibly well written for a character from a series with such little chronological plot. He's got so much more personality than most of the main protagonists, and I personally prefer his faster, more aggressive playstyle in the mainline games over Mario's.
Here's a weird one: Hairadee from Bakugan. Probably my favorite minor villain of the series.
Pac-Man is an ABSOLUTE classic character. Everything about him is simple. His design, games, personality, world but simple in a good way anyone can love. Not to mention he is aboslutely FUN to play as in Smash even though I am TERRIBLE with him. 10/10.
While overall when it comes to Undertale, Sans is BY FAR the most poplar character... but why don't we give my personal favorite member of the cast, Undyne, some time in the spotlight?
Undyne's a pretty neat character that I'd give a 8/10. Aside from coming off as just trying to kill you, she's one of those type of characters that tries to be charming but kinda has a hard time with casual fun if that makes any sense (drawing comparisons to Erza kinda for this). Also, nice thing going on with Alphys obv.
This char is Mista btw, couldn't add a a caption since I'm on mobile.
ah Giorno's Boyfriend I mean Mista, not that knowledgeable on Vento Aureo I will admit but from what I know Mista seems pretty cool. His Tetraphobia is an interesting character quirk, Sex Pistols is a cool stand IMO and I find it amusing how he canonically smells bad. Overall I'd give Mista a solid 7/10
speaking of JoJo anybody got any ratings for BT/SDC Joseph? (I can't post any images from this computer sorry)
I find it hard not to like Joseph. Especially with one of his neater gimmicks being able to predict what you'll say. I think a character who incorporates intelligence into battle and cunningness is a very fun character to watch versus "I have more power in the fists!!!!". It just kind of reinforces you don't have to be ridicullously OP to be a good Shonen protag. Joseph might as well not have as good of Hamon training as Lisa Lisa obviously, his instructors, or even Caesar. Hamon just allows him to be the one to take out Pillar Men with his fighting style.
Aside from that even, he's just a good character and one of the more lighter Jojos, more relaxed. Not like Jotaro who's edgy serious, Giorno the idealist, Jolyne the female Jotaro, etc. Though points off for doing this when Suzi said this...
Ah Broccoli I mean Broly, the swolest of swole lads honestly despite having never seen DB I'm a fan of him just because he seems so over the top in his hatred for KAKAROT, plus he's voiced by the original and best Drunkle also he has a QT Alien GF solid 7.5/10 to me in those aspects.
speaking of characters I have one and I have a picture this time!
Ah my favourite class (after the Reserve Shooter got nerfed fuck that thing) a good Pyro is scary, a fantastic Pyro is an unstoppable menace, sadly I am neither of these things but honestly I still find it fun to piss around with things like the Phlog (yes I am one of those people) 10/10 for Pybro.
anybody got any ratings for Captain Olimar?
@Electric Just to point out, while one sentence character reviews/ratings are allowed on this thread, simply saying that a character is “good” doesn’t properly review them, so I’d like to request that you go into more detail when reviewing characters on this thread in the future instead of simply saying that they are “good”. If you continue to review characters on this thread simply by calling them “good characters”, I will unfortunately have to remove said posts from the thread.
8.5/10 Starfire is wonderful, not in Teen Titans Go! Of course, but in the comics and the O.G. Teen Titans, I like her character concept in the comics it is unique, and she kind of is like a girl version of Superman
9.7/10 I remember seeing doomsday in Batman vs Superman movie, and I remember in the animated Tv show and that same movie how super man died and came back to life, anyway doomsday is kind of like Hulk turned evil that’s why I like him
@Shrek You keep forgetting to add ratings for the characters you review. I’d like to recommend that you take your time with reviewing the characters that are posted on this thread, so you don’t forget to add ratings for them. If you continue to not add ratings when reviewing characters on here, I will have to remove your posts.
Alastor is an interesting character, so to speak. He’s not really portrayed as a villian or antagonist, but rather a guy looking to have fun. Since the show is still developing, I would give him a 7/10, but it might grow to be a 10/10, depending of how they want to go with Alastor.
10/10 I love Star’s characteristics, (if I spelt that right) she is a happy, fun go loving cartoon character, and has a unique development.
I don’t have a picture, but could somebody rate Raven from DC Comics.
@Minor Since no other contributors to this thread seems to know who Scott is (which is evident by the fact that no one has posted on this thread for over a week after you asked Scott to be reviewed), I am unfortunately going to have remove your previous post from the thread in order to prevent the thread from becoming inactive.
@everyone As Minor’s post has now been removed, this means whoever decides to contribute to this thread next will need to review and rate Samus Aran before posting an image of the character they want reviewed.
9/10; All Might is one of my favorite characters in the series, not because of him being heroic, but all of his most badass moments, such as fighting Nomu or Using the United States of Smash on All for one.
Codytlane wrote: IDK this character, but I'll give him a 7/10. I do like the hat.
You... aren't meant to do that.
I just couldn't wait any longer, sorry
Too bad, one of the FIRST RULES is if you don't know the character, do not review them. It pretty much just wastes the other person's time, just to get your character a review. It's also pretty unfair, as your character gets a review, but the other person doesn't.
You've done this before and have been reminded multiple times. It doesn't matter if you couldn't wait any longer, you have to be patient. Please do not do it again.
Buzz Lightyear is a fine character, a good inverse of Woody, but he's just kind of...boy scout-ish, you know? He's not really diverse, apart from the really ham-fisted identity crisis thing in Toy Story 4, which wasn't really funny in the first place. He's fine, but a little bland. 6/10
Continuing with the trend of Pixar characters, Lightning McQueen: