- You must leave a rating/critique for the Thumbnail/Render above yours while also leaving a Thumbnail/Render for someone else to critique.
- The thumbnails and renders MUST be made by you,if it isn't made by you then we will kindly ask that you delete it.
- Only two pictures please, posting more than two will lead to entire walls of text and such so please only post two.
- Try to go into detail when you are giving criticism on a person's Thumbnails, simply giving responses like "The pictures don't match" or "It's good" would only make the game along with the thread boring.
- Please be respectful with your responses (This should be self-explanatory).
- As long as the Thumbnails/Renders are Vs Related then it is allowed, even if it is from another Vs Show (Like Crossover X, One Minute Melee, Cartoon Fight Club, ETC)
- Don't derail the thread.
19,083
pages
ALL POSTSThumbnail Rating Game: Rating Awakens 
<p>Third Thread was at it's Limit, so I decided to just go ahead and Make the Fourth Thread; Here is a Summary for those who may be New.
</p><p>If Someone post a Thumbnail on the thread and if you post a Thumbnail after them, you must say how the person can improve the thumbnail/what could be added/what should be changed/etc. You are a critic essentially, not every thumbnail is perfect and this game is a way for all of us ro help each other on improving the thumbnails we make.
</p><p>Here are the Rules:
</p>
(Edited by Commander Ghost)
0
(Edited by Jershy)
0
Also for Armadillo. I’d give it a 6/10. I understand what you were doing, but I think this lacks a few parts that would make a thumbnail more eye catching. One of the main parts is the background. The background could be used, however, I feel like it needs more effects in order to pull that off effectively. I’d recommend either going for a different one of a similar vibe. Next thing is the backdrop shadow not being present. In a thumbnail like this, I think the shadow is pretty important. Main positive would be the renders. They fit nicely with one another and mesh well. I’ve been seeing improvement in your thumbnails overall tho so that’s good. Keep up the work!
10/10 looks great i love it, the way the background is, the way the characters look, and the heavenly asthetic as well (sorry i ain't that good at making reviews so i decided to add this afterwards after i found the right words to describe it)
(Edited by PedramDoesStuff2)
0
2
(Edited by Jeltz0 z)
(Pedram)
Oh boy, I'm sorry but... 8/20. It's just 2 bland backgrounds with 6 bland renders that all kinda look a tiny bit blurry. It's not really all that good tbh
(Couldn't decide which one to do so I did both)