- You must leave a rating/critique for the Thumbnail/Render above yours while also leaving a Thumbnail/Render for someone else to critique.
- The thumbnails and renders MUST be made by you,if it isn't made by you then we will kindly ask that you delete it.
- Only two pictures please, posting more than two will lead to entire walls of text and such so please only post two.
- Try to go into detail when you are giving criticism on a person's Thumbnails, simply giving responses like "The pictures don't match" or "It's good" would only make the game along with the thread boring.
- Please be respectful with your responses (This should be self-explanatory).
- As long as the Thumbnails/Renders are Vs Related then it is allowed, even if it is from another Vs Show (Like Crossover X, One Minute Melee, Cartoon Fight Club, ETC)
- Don't derail the thread.
19,083
pages
ALL POSTSThumbnail Rating Game: Rating Awakens 
<p>Third Thread was at it's Limit, so I decided to just go ahead and Make the Fourth Thread; Here is a Summary for those who may be New.
</p><p>If Someone post a Thumbnail on the thread and if you post a Thumbnail after them, you must say how the person can improve the thumbnail/what could be added/what should be changed/etc. You are a critic essentially, not every thumbnail is perfect and this game is a way for all of us ro help each other on improving the thumbnails we make.
</p><p>Here are the Rules:
</p>
(Edited by Commander Ghost)
Oh hell yeah! 9/10! The renders mesh well really nicely! The colors and glowing eyes make this feel really clean! My main gripe is that something feels missing, and the overlay isn’t exactly my cup of tea, but otherwise, really good work Anthony!
0
8/10. The renders look awesome and I love the idea of monotone, however, if you're using one color, I recommend making the death battle template in the middle grey too, to go all the way. And just a small criticism, is that the renders are kind of hard to see, but that's a minor concern. Besides that, it looks like an awesome thumbnail and makes sense for the characters.
So Here's Stroheim Vs Ironwood
And Jotaro Vs Jin
2
9/10 for Stroheim vs Ironwood. There's only one real criticism, and that is Ironwood's image is just a bit blurry. Other than that, it looks pretty good.
And 8/10 for Jotaro vs Jin. The guy in the back of Jotaro's image (Who I'm guessing is the stand) makes it seem like a 1v2. It also makes Jin's side look quite empty.
Waluigi vs Waluigi (Mashed vs SMG4)
SSBU DLC Battle Royale
Both are about a 16 or 17/20. They could use a bit more effects, but overall, they aren't that bad
Why did I get a notification for a discussion post from 4 years ago/2020?
1
0
Anyway I'll give it a 7/10. The translucency is cool, but the images themselves just don't work. Maria is facing forward, while the other person is facing to the side. Also it doesn't help that their heads are vastly different sizes, so it would definitely benefit from a few adjustments.
Skid and Pump vs Oogie Boogie
Spooky Month 7: Sound of the Dice
Uh, hmmm. 6/10? I mean, I like the vision. The renders are placed pretty well, and the backgrounds fit pretty well as well. But the lack of anything going on like backdrop shadow or anything makes the thumbnail feel like it was in like, the process of being made instead of finished.
The second thumbnail looks nice tho. The way they are positioned and the render for Oogie Boogie being positioned like that really sells the message of the match. 7/10!
2
^
Pretty good TN, like a 18/20. I like how the galaxy and planets look around the two of them
Yes, it's the same one I posted a few comments ago. I never got my rating on this one