Talk:Mario vs Madoka/@comment-29403514-20190609230539

I very much do not agree with this fight.

The Soul Gem point doesn't apply to Goddess Madoka by the way, it would've been better if you noted it but Kriemhild Gretchen, her witch form, is supposed to be formed out of her Soul Gem being destroyed but was destroyed, meaning she no longer even had a Soul Gem at that point. That should've been noted in the analysis.

Madoka at her peak is arguably Multi-Solar System levels of power with how there are witches that create things such as entire stars (emphasis on the plural) within their labyrinths.

I'm not sure how Mario would even survive one arrow if we're going by how you represented her fighting in this fanon DB. Madoka rewrote four-dimensional space on an infinite scale, making it a Multiversal+ feat. I do know some people don't care much about the VS Battles tiering, but Mario hasn't shown any infinite timelines or universes in of itself to speak of, just a countless amount through the Dream Depot. What I'm getting at is Goddess Madoka would be infinitely superior to Mario in terms of raw power, because infinity divided by countless would still be infinity as infinity is more of an abstract idea than a concrete value. Godoka could pretty much one shot Mario if that was the case, and that speed isn't even out of the question when she literally shifted her existence to a higher plane, putting her above linear time dually.

What I'm getting at is that she easily has the speed to catch Mario and completely one shot for this fight to end. The way that Goddess Madoka, in general, was weird and not really accurate to the character along with a lot of other things for Madoka's section that I could go over, but I wanted to focus on main inaccuracies the fight tried to include. The battle is good for what is written, but I heavily disagree with the verdict personally.