Talk:Soldier vs Captain America/@comment-31287452-20170430210720/@comment-5035900-20180226005717

They've stated a few times on Death Battle Cast that characters who revive over a period of time (ex. a day) would lose in a Death Battle scenario whereas they've yet to cover a character who could literally return from death (or their body's destruction) to the battle in an instant. In that case, that would be a different ballpark altogether.

I think it's like this: say in a hypothetical battle that Doomsday was killed. Sure, he would revive a day or so later immune to what killed him, but in the Death Battle "they've met for the first time" sense, his opponent won and Doomsday still lost.