User blog comment:Pikazilla/SO MUCH WRONG: Silver vs Shredder/@comment-34964696-20170910042845

I've already stated my response to this in the Death Battle Wiki, so I'll shorten it/explain more in detail.

No matter what sword they give to Silver Samurai, it'll work practically the same. Katana + Tachyon = Muramasa + Tachyon.

They were using composite Shredder from the start.

Silver Samurai's armour and rushdown tactics are easy to exploit and predictable respectively. Silver Samurai isn't really anything Shredder hasn't seen nor fought before.

Super Shredder > Tachyon Field. Not in terms of power, but in terms of overall usefulness, especially the teleportation and electricity. Also, if they allow one-time powers for Silver, then they should allow one-time powers for Shredder.

Pointing out small details can affect a battle all together. Even then, they've provided arguments as to why this happened, such as SS' teleportation ring in battle being counteracted by smarter opponents.

Overall, their arguments were plasuible.

As for other Death Battles, yes the NLF argument was brought up, but I'll counter this by saying that Doomsday is just immune to whatever Hulk could throw at him.

Ace would recognize Natsu's fireeating and get scared by it since he doesn't know what would happen if he was eaten while in his fire form.

Lucario VS Renamon was stated to be a no-evolutions fight from the get go. So, adding in the argument that Lucario won simply because they weren't gonna involve outside evolutions is void. Also, if they were gonna involve evolutions, they needed to have trainers to be featured alongside them, which they did not do. (And I know about Renamon's self-evolution). That's not an excuse, it was intentional and planned.

Scaling for Robots makes more sense than scaling for bio-organic beings with no distinct power level or design. So Zero being better than Mega Man in every way works.

18's energy absorption has been addressed to be false. They even spoke out on it. Regardless, it doesn't exactly change the result and Ben explained why. Though I will admit they kinda downplayed Captain Marvel.

I feel like this isn't being mad at cherry picking, but just being mad that certain characters lost. I can respect your agitation, but making a whole post about things that have been explained or can explained is kind of a waste of time. One comment is enough.