Thread:Vrokorta/@comment-36865278-20191119173331/@comment-30408599-20191119193004

"I don't get what you mean by cohesive manner,also the reason i came to the conclusion Mecha scales to Sonic's speed,is because he could keep up with Classic Sonic."

What I mean is that you explain irrelevant situations in too much detail when it'd make more sense to just cover the main idea. For example, you say "in Knuckles' story,it starts with an Eggrobo capturing Knuckles and holding him still,while Mecha Sonic appears and attempts to spindash through him,but Knuckles manages to free himself,causing Mecha to destroy the Eggrobo instead,so him and Knuckles begin to fight.". The main idea is that they fight, but you explain everything about the Eggrobo & Mecha Sonic accidentally destroying him. It'd be a lot more streamlined if you narrowed it down to the important parts.

"I admit,i used the calculations on FC/OC vs battles wiki,which is why i didn't have explanations,so i don't know how to feel."

In that case, it's probably good to link the calc in your battle so viewers can see it themselves. I've done the same thing a couple times.

"Now this is where i want to say my thoughts,i don't wanna sound rude but,what did you expect from a fight from two characters with limited arsenal? i can't make a fight that has a strong feel or intensity to it or that is interesting with two characters that are limited with their things (especially Original Mecha Sonic,he's VERY limited in his moves and powers.)"

I've used a few characters with limited arsenals myself. What I do is create tension through their characters, portray them as highly motivated to defeat their opponent, it makes them & the fight more compelling. I also make the most of what little I have, involve the environment, include stuff from their respective series, & take some creative liberties. Sometimes I'll give characters new forms that don't exist just to make the fight look more interesting or balanced, or I'll have them use their powers in ways that they didn't before, sometimes I'll even slightly tweak their character so characters that don't express themselves much can seem more compelling. As long as it doesn't affect the outcome, I say anything is fair game, just do what you're comfortable with.

"Also,it's not exactly "unexplained" scaling,as like i said before,Mecha Sonic can keep up with Classic Sonic,and also tank hits from him,and plus Original Mecha Sonic is honestly about scaling since that's where most of his feats come from."

I'm not saying him scaling is wrong, it's just that you don't say how strong Classic Sonic is, or what feats make him so strong. While I agree that Classic Sonic is around relatvistic speed, you don't say what feats put him at that level, you just say he traveled the planet, which is a highly variable feat that could give any value depending on the details. That's why I call it unexplained scaling.

I understand where you're coming from, though it doesn't really change my view. If you want to continue the discussion, that's fine, but I gotta go in 15 minutes.