Talk:Percy Jackson vs. Maka Albarn/@comment-3463132-20161016041206/@comment-3463132-20161016060237

Except Percy is neither of those things-

Most certainly not island since literally everything that hits him hurts him- blades, bullets, claws, jaws, horns, tails, fridges, spears, clubs, hooves, wood, fists, the list goes on and on. Percy doesn't tank ANYTHING without taking damage- he's not island in the slightest. If you want to say so be my guest, but there's no good reason to insist that's not only true but more backed up than him being weaker.

And he's not MHS either- he has not one feat to his name of that and several failings that very much go against it. It also requires a very liberal interpretation of a Jason feat that needs to be accepted by exactly nobody to be true. It's literally a guy using the exact quote and saying, "I'll interpret it this way." and then you for some reason expect everyone has to buy it his way and only his way? Nope- not how debating works.

If someone else can look at the same feat and get a very different answer- then the first person's claim is way too flimsy to stand on its own. If you (royal you) have a good argument, then it wouldn't be so easy to find another way of looking at it that's just as plausible.