User blog comment:DoomFest/~The Great Thumbnail Contest - Season 2 ~/@comment-4363364-20160415131712/@comment-26561766-20160415192251

Yes, I see the problem. Is the Shadow's pic a fanart or an official atwork ?

I will give you moy opinions on the others :

- For the fourth one (with the legend "Second"), I like the idea of both charging an attack, but here the difference of zoom is a problem. Moreover, having the name of the character written on the pic doesn't really make it more beautiful. It's not a good pic to use for Shadow in my opinion.

- For the two pics based on the armor theme, the first one is definitely better. The style of drawing between the two pics is closer, and the gap of close-up is less important. Moreover the background of the Mewtwo's pic is awesome in the first thumbnail while in the second it doesn't really fit Shadow's.

Nevertheless, I do like the Shadow's pic used in the second thumbnail.

But in all honestly, there isn't any thumbnail that I can call "bad" in all the thumbnails you show me.