Talk:Madoka Kaname X Guu/@comment-27847494-20160222135131/@comment-27847494-20160222161318

Everywhere only means the Multiverse when a Multiverse actually exists and sometimes not even then and it needs to be specified. Canon never showed a Multiverse. It showed multiple timelines, which as resident Time Traveler can attest too weren't directly altered (or she couldn't have vague memories of witches the premise for the Movie). But it never traveled back and forth between multiple timelines to show us that Madoka's wish affected previous timelines Even multiple timelines contained inside a universe isn't nessecarily a Multiverse.

Kyuubey talked about a lot of stuff and when it talked about Madoka it talked about her altering the Universe. Not multiple universes. The way Kyuubey talked about the other timelines and how they focused things on Madoka, at the same time. If other timelines were considered other universes in this universe, then Homura creating multiple timelines should have been a lot more shocking to Kyuubey as she was creating other universes. It was not the case. Then comes Madoka and her reality warping wish.

You can't take narrative headcanons as facts for Deathbattle. You can only use hard evidence. real facts and examples of things that actually happened in the canon.