Talk:Simba VS Firestar/@comment-33279205-20180506025132

Firestar won because

1: he defeated Simba first

2: that tree falling wasn't Simba's fault. Firestar had jumped from a crapton of trees to other trees, so the one he was next to very likely wasn't the one Simba threw Firestar to.

3: Even if it was the very same Simba threw Firestar to, Simba couldn't have possibly thrown Firestar with enough force to weaken a tree to the point of toppling over later after. He would've overshot it or undershot it if he could take a tree down with a living projectile.

4: Firestar has 9 lives, Simba has 1. Even if Firestar died during the fight, if Simba had killed Firestar 8 times or less Firestar could've still have survived.

5: Firestar could've survived the tree anyways had he had 9 lives for the fight. it would only take one life, then he would be back, good as new.

Things that should've been considered during the battle:

Firestar would've had to have killed Simba from blood loss, provided the location where he jumped from from to deal the final blow. That's his only choice up there. He would've had to slid under Simba, and clawed through Simba's belly, and it would've only slit through a small part of the heart, which i'm not even sure is sufficiently fatal to kill Simba fast enough for Firestar to stall it out. the heart is located that far down in a lion.

Lions have claws.

Plot events that should've been considered:

Sandstorm wasn't a warrior until well after Spottedleaf was slain. and even if this was their StarClan selves, Sandstorm and Firestar weren't in Starclan themselves until Spottedleaf's Starclan self was sadly killed by another cat. And if it's their Starclan selves how tf did a lion who doesn't know a word about StarClan get up there as well?!

Obviously Firestar's friends would've had to help and not just stare in 'shock' at the ongoing battle. some nice friends and mate Firestar has!