Talk:Ichigo vs Nightmare/@comment-37645040-20181219233702/@comment-37645040-20181220204504

ok i'm just going to provide criticism. not trying to sound harsh i'm just doing.

the post analysis was attrocious. not only was it INSANELY short, but the reasoning why felt like it was ripped straight out from Vs. Battles wiki with no elaboration to bring up how. Nightmare's Planetary strength? how? You don't provide such evidence as why but for Durability you said he tanked hit's from Algol who is planetary and scaling from Nightmare and Algol is capricious

Since when the hell did Nightmare cannonly fought Nightmare? If your referring to arcade mode, then it isn't really cannon to Soul Calibur's lore. If that's the case, Voldo, Ivy, Talim, Astaroth, Maxi and others would be planetary level cause "They defeated and tanked hits from Algol". Besides it would most likely being an outlier if it was cannonically, since Nightmare never displayed the same strength as Algol as or even greater. if this is the case then Batman would be on the same level of Spectre cause he was able to hurt him with a kick. Or Black Panther being on the same level of Silver Surfur cause he tanked hits from Silver Surfer attacks.

Also: " nightmare can move Massive planets and dwarf stars with ease."

Where the hell did this come from exactly?

Honestly I feel shaky for this one. The Reason I believe Sam's reasoning why ichigo would beat Nightmare is because he actually elaborated on his statements on how Ichigo had the advantages that you gave to Nightmare. Not trying to be hateful just like I said, provide criticism