Talk:Kamek vs. Twilight Sparkle/@comment-37428813-20181208225657/@comment-32507967-20190210050028

I used a culmination of all forms of the characters, and read every MLP Comic I could get my hands on in preparation for this battle. Many of the spells I list for her only happen in the comics, in fact. When this was released, the movie didn't exist.

1. Yes. One character wins because they're the hero, and one character loses because they're the villain - both in their own stories. But if one is generally mor epowerful than the other, it doesn't really matter in regards to a Death Battle scenario - e.g. Ben and Chad have gone on record stating that if the T-850 (from the original trilogy) were to fight the T-1000 in a Death Battle, the T-850 would lose. But it wins in the movie. Because it's the hero.

2. I'm...trying to make sense of this. I'm not sure what point you're trying to make, but as far as I can tell, you're saying that all magic is infinite (despite the fact that Twilight has been affected by other magic and bested by more powerful magic many times), and that Alicorns are said to be gods, which...means something, apparently? Anyone can call anybody a god, but it makes them no more powerful than they were before. Besides, it's clear that all Alicorns have limits to their powers and magic, and Twilight's was mor elimited than all of them as of Season 6, which is when this fight was written.

3. But nothing would change even if the characters WERE in a bloodlust. And there have been multiple official battles (e.g. Goku vs. Superman, Akuma vs. Shang Tsung) where a combatant has hesitated or outright refused to kill the other due to teh situation and their personalities.

4. The German comics. Read them sometime; they're pretty wacky.

5. No. Because Dr. Fate can remove magical protection and wards. Other than that, I mean, Peach's Heart Power could give protection from Dreamy Bowser, a universe-level threat, despite Peach being NOWHERE NEAR that level of power. So clearly magical protection in the Mario world is OP. And there are plenty of times where Twilight struggles with affecting powerful magic users in both the show and comics, much less one directly protected from magical influence.

6. Um, why is Twilight "out of the universe"? Or godlike? Or ridiculously smart? I mean, she's certainly quite intelligent, but...Bowser has a confirmed IQ of 9,800. And he's said Kamek's smarter than him. Soooooo...hey, remember that time Twilight was possessed and made legaues smarter than she had ever been before? And was still tricked by Pinkie Pie? That was a fun comic story.