Talk:Madoka Kaname/@comment-27847494-20160222142335

Alright, so I asked questions in one of the fanon deathbattles here but lets put some deeper things here. First, let's review some of these well... clearly exaggerated abilities with canon to disprove them. Blatantly false. Magical Girls are clearly harmed by damage to their body not their Soul Gem. It costs them magical power to restore it. And since they cast all magical powers from their Soul Gem, harming their body is indirectly corrupting their soul bringing them closer to witchhood. If this 'was' true Sayaka's main magical power, regeneration, made no sense.
 * Body takes no damage without Soul Gem getting hit

Since hse has no actual memories of these things this isn't a feat. There was no tangile evidence for this. We are shown that she dreams of Homura before she has met Homura due likely to Homura's time travel. We do know that Madoka's power keeps increasing from new timelimes.
 * Has defeated countless witches thanks to Homura resetting the timeline over and over

The only proof of this is her sneaking into the isolated space of Homura's Soul Gem and a huge part of this is that her Goddess Domain would have sooner or later forced the issue. But traveling to an isolated part of your own dimension is not 'flying through dimensions' which implies something more like Planeswalking. Baseless claim. Homura almost dispproves this. If she existed in 'all' timelines and 'all' universes. Then Homura wouldn't remember her, who comes from a timeline without Madokami. We know she exists throughout the timline she was born in. But our resident time traveler resisted reality changing to make Madoka Kamae (pre-kami) not have ever existed. She was affected by the reality rewrite, but eventually recalled information from other timelines.
 * Can fly through dimensions
 * Exists in all timelines, across all universes

Now, it 'may' be possible, as fanon, that she exists in all timelines. But as we are never shown other timelines (just another universal rewrite). Feats demand factual proof. Powers based on theories and headcanon don't fly.

On what proof is this claim of more than one plane? We are shown one reality where she is in control, and that reality is rewritten, but she didn't exist on both of those realities at the same time. She couldn't even exist both inside Homura's Isolated Soul and Outside it at the same time, that was the whole reason to send in an agent to work on the inside at first. What does it even mean by plane? She exists in the past present and future as a force of nature which she does all of this, yes.
 * Now saves Magical Girls from their fates, watches over humanity, and fights her own witch all at once thanks to existing on more than one plane