User blog comment:The Irish VS Writer/Luke Skywalker vs Rey/@comment-38210990-20190930094900

Luke takes it due to the fact he's much more experience then Rey at using both the lightsaber and force. Plus, Luke uses the force more in combat then Rey who mainly only uses the weapon she has on her. Luke definity has more "Force abilities" then Rey like creating a forcefield, redirect energy blasts and using the force speed

So, in the end, I think Luke would take this one but who knows, Rey might become Star Wars god in Episode 9.