Talk:Fairy Tail vs Fate/Stay Night/@comment-3463132-20180808200638

So it's:

1.Natsu Dragneel 2.Gray Fullbuster 3.Lucy Heartfilia 4.Erza Scarlet 5.Mirajane Strauss 6.Gajeel Redfox 7.Cana Abellrona 8.Wendy Marvell 9.Juvia Lockser 10.Laxus Dreyar 11.Gildart Clive

VS

1.Saber/Arturia Pendragon 2.Lancer/Cú Chulain 3.Archer/Emiya 4.Rider/Medusa 5.Caster/Medea 6.Gilgamesh 7.Berserker/Heracles 8.Rin Tohsaka 10.Kirei Kotomine 9.Emiya Shirou 11.Sasaki Kojiro

Gotta side pretty heavily with Fairy Tail on that one.

Shirou can't match anyone for shit- WoG he only could fight Gilgamesh and the like because he was basically having a one-in-a-million perfect day where everything aligned to make him able to do anything, "A miracle". That's not applicable to a Deathbattle when even the writer says, "Yeah that was bull." All of the magus are basically going to die from the side-effects of the stronger battles and that leaves Fate at a disadvantage right off the bat- none of them can take a Servant or a servant-level opponent head-on and win.

Medusa's gaze can be resisted by anyone with significant magic power- which ALL of Fairy Tail has by the bucket-full. Gilgamesh is walking CIS and it's outright stated multiple times that he has it so he's going to be arrogant, going to not take this seriously, and is going to be defeated because of it; like basically every other time he shows up. Medea needs prep to be her most effective and she would not have it here.

That leaves basically Saber, Archer, Berserker, and Lancer to carry against Fairy Tail. Them's not good odds. Lancer's Gae Bolg is a surefire kill but he has to get way closer to Fairy Tail than he has any business wanting to be and depending on who he attacks it might not work anyways (Juvia becomes entirely water for example). Berserker is going to be hard to kill but Erza has the exact same advantage Gilgamesh did- plenty of high-quality weapons. Natsu and Gray meanwhile are packing Saber's advantage where they can just blast multiple lives out with one go