Thread:Vrokorta/@comment-36865278-20191119173331/@comment-36865278-20191119185014

It's fine.

Anyways,i'll start.

"Mecha Sonic's analysis is good, but it's a little unspecific. Like when you talk about Mecha Sonic's interactions with Sonic & Knuckles, you say what happened rather than explaining it in a cohesive manner. You also say Mecha scales to Sonic's speed, but you don't say exactly what speed he scales to, or what feat makes him this fast. It might make people question your research if you don't have solid facts that you've proven, as your research is supposed to be your proof, & without proof, it's like you didn't research. I mean no offense, I just think it'd be a good idea to explain your info more."

I don't get what you mean by cohesive manner,also the reason i came to the conclusion Mecha scales to Sonic's speed,is because he could keep up with Classic Sonic.

"TMS' analysis was good too, but again, I think you could've explained your calculations more, as all you say is what he did, & how strong it was. Not once do you mention how it was calced, which is kind of important for making a convincing argument. Besides that, it seems like you covered TMS pretty well."

I admit,i used the calculations on FC/OC vs battles wiki,which is why i didn't have explanations,so i don't know how to feel.

"The fight was okay, but a bit monotonous, & didn't have a strong feel or intensity to it. I just feel like it dragged on for too long.

The outcome is reasonable, but I think it relies too much on unexplained scaling rather than realistic & proven research.

Overall, a fine battle, but not all that interesting.

5/10"

Now this is where i want to say my thoughts,i don't wanna sound rude but,what did you expect from a fight from two characters with limited arsenal? i can't make a fight that has a strong feel or intensity to it or that is interesting with two characters that are limited with their things (especially Original Mecha Sonic,he's VERY limited in his moves and powers.)

Also,it's not exactly "unexplained" scaling,as like i said before,Mecha Sonic can keep up with Classic Sonic,and also tank hits from him,and plus Original Mecha Sonic is honestly about scaling since that's where most of his feats come from.

Hopefully this doesn't come as offensive or rude,and that's all i wanted to say.