Talk:Amy Rose vs Rosalina/@comment-30408599-20190131181314/@comment-27518422-20190131184932

"And I thought I downplayed Rosalina" Erm, thanks. I guess.

Strength and Durability: The outcome of Mario vs Sonic should bear no influence on any other match. Otherwise there would be no sense in doing another Mario vs Sonic themed match; "Comparable to Mario and Screw Attack said Mario beats Sonic so there" is the general jist I get from that logic. Yeah, Rosalina made a strong forcefield but the Lumas seemed to plug the explosion that would have caused catastrophe. They used their strength to create a new galaxy. Even if Rosalina's field held Amy off, it doesn't really turn this into a victory. Amy wins this category because Rosalina has no feats of combat particularly.

Speed: The speed of one's vehicle does not make the user that fast. Rosalina hardly even moves in SMG and when she does move in the other Mario games she's not going too fast. At all. Amy obviously isn't as fast as Sonic but she can consistently run at speeds to keep up with him. Amy wins the speed category.

Intelligence: Rosalina is smarter than Amy, I am not gonna pretend otherwise. But she is smart in the wrong subjects for this. She built a ship and was smart enough to care for Lumas. Bravo to her. It won't help in a Death Battle.

Experience: Rosalina is unlocked after World 8 and only becomes playable after the villains are beaten once. So no, I won't count that. Rosalina didn't do any fighting in Galaxy. If she were so powerful as everyone says, she would have fought Bowser alone. She didn't. Amy on the other hand, has been a Freedom Fighter and even aided the resistance against Eggman's Empire in Sonic Forces. She is willing to go on the front lines and fight. Unlike Rosalina. So Amy is more battle hardened than Rosalina.

Abilities/Arsenal: Rosalina has a wider one, but Amy's is more effective. Rosalina's arsenal was more set to offset and annoy Amy rather than deal any finishing impact. Amy didn't need to land too many hits to kill Rosalina however. It was only a matter of time.

I have read your work, but I disagreed with her winning the battle royal. Another big factor is that I never use Power Scaling or Tiers/Levels so it can be harder to debate with me because of that.