Thread:Arigarmy/@comment-27150398-20171112205645/@comment-27150398-20180209215417

Also, TJ previously suggested that a 'What-If Death Battle Appreciation thread' be created where users could link their completed fights and get other people to read and comment on them. I orginally dismissed the idea but after thinking about it in more detail, I think it could work if some ground rules are put in place.

The main rule would be that when a user posts a battle they would have to leave a comment about the previous user's battle, underneath the battles that they've posted (similar to how users have leave comments about each other's TN's in this thread) so that everyone who posted fights on said thread could be sure that there fights would be read. Other rules would be that each user could only post two battles at any one time so that the user responding to them wouldn't have to spend ages commenting about said battles and that each user would have to wait another week before they could post any more of their fights on the thread. Users would also have to be polite about the battle their commenting on even if they believed that it wasn't good and to offer constructive criticism if they thought that it needed improving and would be encouraged to comment on specific details of the fight to prove that they've read it, rather than just leaving a vague 'your fight was great!' type of comment.

I personally think that this type of thread would help to encourage more people to write What-If? Death Battles whilst also encouraging them to continuously write battles in the future so that they could receive postive feedback about them, however if you don't think that this would be a good idea, please let me know.