Talk:Shadow the Hedgehog VS Majin Buu/@comment-26941217-20151121174316

Good job on the fight, but I honestly disagree.

"Shadow has only beaten Sonic once." No he hasn't - he's beaten him numerous times, even knocking Super Sonic out cold, who is invincible. He has also defeated Mephiles, Silver, Iblis, Solaris, Black Doom and Devil Doom, who I'm pretty sure could all obliterate a planet or two if they felt like it.

Super Shadow doesn't have a time limit - In Sonic Advanced, Sonic could stay in his super form for as long as he wanted. What's there to say that Shadow couldn't do the same?

If Super Shadow DID run out for whatever reason, he would return to normal at his peak. I'm pretty sure he would be able to tank a "gigantic beam" from Buu in this scenario. Also, Shadow wouldn't just sit around and let the beam hit him. He's smart, so chances are he'd get out of the way.

Don't want to sound like a butthurt fanboy or anything, but I think Shadow takes this. It wouldn't be a stomp though, but I think Shadow has the means to put Buu down. I'm not going to hate you for it like most Sonic fans would - it was a really well written fight. Good job.