User blog comment:Fedora Lord Para 348/Death Battle Fanon Wiki Hall of Records/@comment-25421952-20150305130800/@comment-27822848-20150305154730

They would appear as different battles.

For example, Scorpion, Ryu, Deadpool, and Deathstroke all have entries for their canon battles and their what-if? battles. If, say, Lloyd vs. Kirito was turned into a real battle and Kirito won, I'd put that down as a win for Kirito and a loss for Lloyd even though Lloyd won in the what-if? version.