Talk:Amy Rose vs Rosalina/@comment-30408599-20190131181314

And I thought I downplayed Rosalina.

It was a good fight, but I disagree. Here's how I think it would go.

Strength & Durability: Amy can fight the same enemies as Sonic. While definitely weaker, she's still comparable to him. However, in Mario 3D World, Rosalina can fight the same enemies as Mario. However, he's a Star Child, & she's not, so she's probably not as strong. To put it shortly, Mario is stronger than Sonic, so Rosalina would be stronger than Amy. Not only that, but Rosalina's forcefields blocked the universe's destruction at the end of SMG, so she could negate all damage from Amy.

Speed: Amy can keep up with Sonic, who's about 9X the speed of light. However, Rosalina could pilot the Comet Observatory to the center of the galaxy in a relatively short amount of time, which is MFTL+ for her reactions at least, MUCH faster than Amy or Sonic.

Intelligence: I think this one's pretty straightforward. Amy's a kid with not much going for her. Rosalina's several hundred years old & helped build the Comet Observatory.

Experience: While you make a good point about age=/=experience, you REALLY downplay Rosalina here. In Mario 3D World, she's fought every boss sans Bowser. She may not have as much experience as Amy, but she has more than you give her credit for.

Abilities/Arsenal: Between her Lumas. magical powers, & power-ups from 3D World, Rosalina should have arsenal covered. To my knowledge, Amy doesn't have much of an arsenal.

So yeah, I think Rosalina should've won. If you want more insight on my opinion, I've made two fights with Rosalina in it, you can check them out on my profile.