Talk:Fairy Tail vs Fate/Stay Night/@comment-3463132-20180808200638/@comment-33586967-20190408024929

Okay, I will disagree with the overall result but I do agree with most of your points.

Okay first off, literally anyone harms Saber, Gilgamesh will just slaughter them like he did Medea in the Fate route. On the topic of Gilgamesh, he does not have to be serious to eliminate anyone in Fairy Tail minus Natsu, since his gates fire weapons like Excalibur or Gae Bolg(while Erza just has decent magical weaponry and she has a limit unlike Gilgamesh), also if he gets serious, which will probably be late game, it is over Ea absolutely destroys everyone on the field at the same time(minus Saber)

Second Saber has Avalon which makes her immortal, so legit nobody in Fairy Tail could actually finish her. Also pro magic is an A rank which means no one besides Erza or Gildharts would actually be able to harm her and even then she tanked a blast form Ea, not at full power but enough to kill legit anyone in fairy tail minus Natsu.

Third off Erza CANNOT do what Gil did because while Erza has a lot of good weapons, Gil can summon more of them and he actually had to use Enkidu(which Erza does not have something of an equivalent to) to restrain Herc before he died the last time also she cannot summon them as fast nor fire them as fast, at least in my opinion.

4th Lancer's protection from arrows would stop any long-range magical attack so half of Fairy Tail could not work against him, though the stronger half could but unless your name is Natsu you will probably die against him.

5th Archer kinda bodies anyone who lets him get range since he can literally spam mini-nukes, even if someone like Natsu gets close he took 6 lives from Herc in one route so he should be fine as long as it was 1v1.

Medusa did last without her gaze vs opponents like Saber alter, albeit with help, and while they are tough Fairy Tail has not shown much actual resistance(minus dragonslayers or something like them being immune to their element) to magic more like just endurance.

But yeah Shirou, Rin, and Kotomine will just die Kijiro could fight Erza for a little while but he will just die as well. Medea could put up a fight but they are just tough not Magic resistant and Rule Breaker exists, though in this matchup I don't see it working for too long especially since she could barely hold off Saber by herself.

So overall in my opinion this ends up being a 5 or 6 v 1 with Natsu as the only survivor from Fairy tail, since he is in a different tier from his friends, vs Gilgamesh, Artoria, Cu, Emyia Archer, Hercules(he would have lost a few lives by now though), and maybe Medusa and we all know how that will end up.