Talk:Tifa Lockhart vs Yang Xiao Long/@comment-35561433-20180616025149/@comment-3463132-20181211054528

I mean you can't really call it "fair game" when Deathbattle clearly had access to the information for both battles and didn't use it for Tifa. She doesn't scale to Zack. Just because they used a feat for Zack doesn't mean they find the scaling acceptable to use for Tifa- which to be fair indeed she deserves scaling least out of all the FF7 characters.

And I never understood why people wanted to use Huge Materia scaling like it means anything. Huge Materia have that much energy when detonated as pure explosive power- something no other materia is used for. Especially when we've seen materia used by villains who have no reason to hold back and the showings aren't remotely near megatons of energy. If the stuff was blown up like a bomb sure- but it's not.

That's also assuming materia always works the same when SE has pretty clearly shown this isn't the case. Materia works differently every time the stuff is portrayed: FF7, DoC, Advent Children, and Crisis Core- all do it differently. It's impossible to assert almost anything about materia because of this.